Comparison
Carnegie Mellon University vs Arizona State University
MS Computer Science · Pittsburgh, PA vs MS Computer Science (Online) · Tempe, AZ
Last reviewed: July 2026
Short answer: Arizona State University (MS Computer Science (Online)) is the cheaper program overall, Carnegie Mellon University (MS Computer Science) reports the higher starting salary, and Carnegie Mellon University (MS Computer Science) pays back fastest against the standard ₹8L India baseline. Carnegie Mellon University (MS Computer Science)currently has the stronger post-study work / visa pathway. No single program wins on everything - which one is actually "better" depends on your budget, priority (salary vs. migration vs. affordability), and your own admit odds.
| Carnegie Mellon University | Arizona State University | |
|---|---|---|
| Country | USA | USA |
| City | Pittsburgh, PA | Tempe, AZ |
| Duration | 16 months | 24 months |
| Total cost | ₹1.02Cr | ₹95.2L |
| Avg. starting salary | ₹1.24Cr/yr | ₹81.1L/yr |
| Payback period | 0.9 yrs | 1.3 yrs |
| Visa pathway | Strong | Strong |
| Min. GPA (4.0 scale) | 3.6 | 3.0 |
| Test requirement | No fixed minimum; GRE optional but recommended for weaker profiles | GRE typically waived |
| Consultant-oversold flag | No | Yes - our editorial flag |
Carnegie Mellon University: the honest note
Elite CS program with strong FAANG placement. STEM OPT gives up to 3 years of US work authorization post-grad, but converting to H-1B afterward has gotten harder for entry-level hires since 2026 (see visa risk flag).
Arizona State University: the honest note
High acceptance rate - heavily marketed by consultants; large program with outcomes that vary widely by individual effort. Post-OPT H-1B conversion has also gotten harder for entry-level hires since 2026 (see visa risk flag).
How payback is calculated
Payback = total program cost ÷ (starting salary abroad − ₹8,00,000 India baseline). The baseline rises for IIT/NIT-class graduates, which lengthens payback for those students on both programs above. Full formula and worked example in the payback period guide.
Sources
Carnegie Mellon University: Tuition & requirements: cmu.edu/sfs, csd.cmu.edu admissions · Salary band: Glassdoor / Indeed / PayScale / ZipRecruiter (Jul 2026) · Visa: USCIS STEM OPT policy · H-1B changes: $100k supplemental fee (USCIS Presidential Proclamation, effective Sep 21, 2025) + wage-weighted lottery (USCIS final rule, effective Feb 27, 2026), uscis.gov
Arizona State University: Tuition: asuonline.asu.edu (2026-27) · Salary band: Glassdoor / Indeed / PayScale / ZipRecruiter (Jul 2026) · Visa: USCIS STEM OPT policy · H-1B changes: $100k supplemental fee (USCIS Presidential Proclamation, effective Sep 21, 2025) + wage-weighted lottery (USCIS final rule, effective Feb 27, 2026), uscis.gov
Want this run on your actual profile, not just these two?
The Honest Scorecard ranks every program you're considering against your GPA, budget, and priorities - admit odds, payback, and visa strength, all sourced.
Get My Free Assessment